YET TO BE ENTERED INTO BY NHRC OF INDIA (AS ON 10.8.2015) THIS IS A WELL KNOWN CASE TO NHRC / INDIA OVER 5 / 6 YEARS & SEVERAL REFERENCES HAVE BEEN MADE BY NHRC TO RAILWAYS. RAILWAYS NEVER RESPOND TO NHRC RATHER IGNORED TO REPLY TO NHRC. IN SUCH CIRCUMSTANCE REASON FOR NON ENTER IN TO REFERENCE BY NHRC / INDIA CAN NOT BE UNDERSTOOD.
Submitted on 10.8.2015 as a reminder by Chinmay Kar
*****************************************
NHRC COMPLAIN /
CLAIM CASE D.No. 1413453 dated 06-01-2014 in respect of claim case
between Chinmay Kar – Vs- Indian Railways
Copy of
documents placed below for ready reference in connection with NHRC D.No.
1413453 DATED 06-01-2014
Chinmay Kar 6th
January'2014
On Friday,
27 December 2013 10:40 AM, Chinmay Kar <chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
Disabler's Desk - I am a
Retd. Sr. Citizen (69+yrs), Hemaparasis Disabled (60%), right side of
body fully paralyzed, cannot move out side with out an escort but can only
operate computer / internet with unusual left hand to communicate rest part of
world especially in connection with social welfare works for betterment to old
age disability and disabled persons Received 17 Railway Awards during later
part services at Metro Railway-Kolkata but as a Retd. Disabled Sr.Citizen
neglected / ignored by all - Chinmay Kar
[A CASE OF
SR.CITIZEN, PARALYZED DISABLED, CANNOT MOVE OUT SIDE W/O ESCORT & fully
dependent on e-governance system]
WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW
REMINDER- 169- Dated. 27-12-2013
[Silence for 3261 Days Since = 07-06-2009 ]
To
Sri. Arunendra Kumar
Chairman
Railway Board
Sri.
Mallikarjun Kharge
Minister of
Indian Railways, Govt. of
India
Copy to:- all Principle officers at Railway Board & all others- including
persons referred earlier for
kind information & necessary action.
National
Human Right Commission against NHRC Registration No. 5907 / 30 / 3 / 2013, 117
/ 25 / 5 / 2013 & 111 / 25 / 5 / 2013
NHRC [nhrc.india@nic.in , jrlawnhrc@nic.in ] for kind information & record in
reference to above. Formal request is being made separately by this extreme
disabled. Claim notice served on railways on 22.12,2012 followed by
weekly reminders during past one year duly copy endst to you & others.
PM [PMO] This particular case is
brought his knowledge. Kindly refer correspondences made in this respect.
[THIS BEING VIEWED BY EVERY ONE HENCE NO SPL. ATTN.
INVITED]
Priyo Mahoday,
Sub: A very simple prayer on
Humanity ground by a Retd. Disabled, Sr.Citizen of India , Humanitarian prayers
made through 168 letters
/ reminders sufficiently available with you may kindly be connected seen. [ In case if you are
unable to response for whatsoever reasons then please convey on behalf of
Indian Railways that “Railway authority itself is Disabled hence can not render
help / assist a Senior Citizen, Paralyzed Disabled who cannot move outside with
out an escort”.]
Ref: [1]
Kindly see attachment: A self detailed prayer made through100th reminders to you.
[Details of 100+ reminders with all other
imputes already available with you in sufficient numbers. Latest being Reminder
No. 168]
Ref: [II]
Compensation Claim letter dated 22.12.2012 followed by reminders every week
through registered reminders]
Kind
attention is invited to the submissions made through letter followed by
reminder letters, mails along with compensation claim letter dated 22.12.2013
followed through reminders every week for the past one year, quoted above
placed at attachment for ready reference.
Hope you
will realize your stand / situation / dealings to an old aged paralyzed
disabled can’t move without escorts for whatsoever reasons as detailed at
prayers, clarifications made and do needful immediately. Thanking you,
Namaskaram,
Chinmay Kar 27th Dec’2013 REMINDER- 169
[Due to extreme
disability reasons E- governance correspondence solicited]
[Available on Skype,
gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
kyinu1955@
gmail.com
Visit respective Web site
for more details:
Human Right Activist-
Yahoo Group, Active Member Disability International Friendship Forum, Humanist
Party of India , DAND, NCHRO, ADR. Member all leading Disabled
forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter, MySpace,
Linkedin, Orckut etc etc & Ex. President (for a decade up to 21.02.03
- become hemaparasis disabled) of Siddeswari Kali Mandir & Seva Sangha,
Gandhipalli, Bongaon, North-24 Parganas,West Bengal, India.
*** Disabler's Desk - I am a Retd.
Sr. Citizen (69+yrs), Hemaparasis Disabled (60%), right side of body fully
paralyzed, cannot move out side with out an escort but can only operate
computer / internet with unusual left hand to communicate rest part of world
especially in connection with social welfare works for betterment to old age
disability and disabled persons Received 17 Railway Awards during later part
services at Metro Railway-Kolkata but as a Retd. Disabled Sr.Citizen
neglected / ignored by all - Chinmay Kar
-à For all correspondences please
use this address
[Paschinmara, Bongaon,
North 24 Parganas, West Bengal , India.{Permanent
Residence)] [FOR CORRESPONDENCE
PURPOSE TILL FURTHER NOTICE]
Kolkata address: Will
be notified as and when I am available on medical consideration.
ATTACHMENTS
1. 100+ Reminder [Copies already
available with you]
2. Compensation claim letter dated 22-12-2012 [Copies already available with you]
3. SUBJECT OF LETTERS WILL
SPEAK FOR ITSELF
4. Reminder No.168
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
REMINDER- 168- Dated. 10-12-2013
[Silence for 3244 Days Since = 07-06-2009 ]
To
Sri.
Mallikarjun Kharge
Minister of
Indian Railways, Govt. of
India
Sri.
Adhir Ranjan Choudhury,
Sri. Arunendra Kumar
Chairman
Railway Board
Copy to all
Principle officers at Railway Board & all others- including
persons referred earlier for
kind information & necessary action. National Human Right Commission
against NHRC Registration No. 5907 / 30 / 3 / 2013, 117 / 25 / 5 / 2013 &
111 / 25 / 5 / 2013
[THIS BEING VIEWED BY EVERY ONE HENCE NO SPL. ATTN.
INVITED]
Priyo Mahoday,
Sub: A very simple prayer on
Humanity ground by a Retd. Disabled, Sr.Citizen of India , Humanitarian prayers
made through 149 letters
/ reminders sufficiently available with you may kindly be connected seen. [ In case if you are
unable to response for whatsoever reasons then please convey on behalf of
Indian Railways that “Railway authority itself is Disabled hence can not render
help / assist a Senior Citizen, Paralyzed Disabled who cannot move outside with
out an escort”.] Please see the subjects
of reminders 100 onwards only at annexure, so that you need not go through
letters to study case.
Ref: [1]
Kindly see attachment: A self detailed prayer made through100th reminders to you.
[Details of 100+ reminders with all other
imputes already available with you in sufficient numbers.]
It is hoped that some
fine morning some kind hearted administrative authority may think twice and
deny arguments placed before you…….. keeping in view the theme of INTERNATIONAL DAY FOR
DISABILITY – 2012 Excuse me for inviting your kind attention to the prayers made to
Railway Minister during Miss Mamata Banerjee’s period for consideration
of allowing my escort to accompany me in coach I am traveling owing to my
absolute disability and allied reasons. Prayer has been made purely on
humanitarian, religious, absolute disability & pilgrimage reasons by a
Retd. Sr.Citien, Extreme Disabled / Disability person at the fag end of his
life for due consideration as a token of cognition of services rendered,
appreciated by Railways through 17 awards. I am well aware that existing rules
does not cater such provision but rules are made by human being only & not
by Lord God or treated as provision of Bible, but necessity, justification
demands change, amendment, consideration on humanitarian reasons. Hope
Government of India acting through the
Railway Ministry will not debar this aged couple (ornamentally termed as Senior
Citizen of India) in performing their religious intentions already narrated
before you & your predecessors. In this respect it will not be out of place
to mention that expenditure likely to be incurred in allowing the prayed issue
will be absolutely negligible from finance point of view and as such there
should be no reason to hold on decision for indefinite time. Incidentally with an
intention to visit Ma Tara Temple at Tara pith, Kamrup Kamakhya
at Gauhati, Tirupati Devasthanam, Hardwar etc to offer Puja for betterment of
all of us submitted pass application to GM / M.Rly / Kolkata during past three
years. Sorry till date since no directive issued from Rail Board’s
office, escort could not be included in pass by concerned GM. All religious
programmed made had to be cancelled on account of railways. Thus continuously
debarred to perform religious obligations at the fag end of life which is
virtually my constitutional right. Kind attention is also invited to Declaration on the Rights of Disabled
Persons Proclaimed by General Assembly resolution 3447 (XXX) of 9
December 1975 / 2007 especially matters pertaining to Differential Treatment to a PERSON WITH
DISABILITY , please see link:http://www.ohchr.org/EN/ProfessionalInterest/Pages/RightsOfDisabledPersons.aspx
. Hope you will be kind
enough to study the entire situation & issue suitable instructions as
prayed for to the concerned GM / M.Rly /Kolkata., copy to undersigned as
immediately as possible and oblige. Kindly don’t hesitate to tell your
constraints if any. Escort will be chosen by PWD himself. Incidentally it is
mentioned that the delay resulted deterioration of my disability which may
kindly be noted. A separate formal reference in this regard has been made with present CRB Sri.V.Mittal / Sri.
Arunendra Kumar for compensation payment in this regard vide letter dated
22.12.2012 may be seen and immediate necessary
action is taken.
It may kindly be noted that by allowing time the appeal made for escort will
have a corresponding raise of amount claimed as compensation for rupees one and
half lakhs per year or a part thereof..
Namaskaram,
Attachment:
Compensation claim [Copies already available with you]
Chinmay
Kar 10th Dec’2013
REMINDER- 168
[Due to extreme
disability reasons E- governance correspondence solicited]
[Available on Skype,
gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
kyinu1955@
gmail.com
Visit respective Web
site for more details:
Human
Right Activist- Yahoo Group, Active Member Disability International Friendship
Forum, Humanist Party of India , DAND, NCHRO, ADR. Member all leading Disabled
forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter, MySpace,
Linkedin, Orckut etc etc & Ex. President (for a decade up to 21.02.03
- become hemaparasis disabled) of Siddeswari Kali Mandir & Seva Sangha,
Gandhipalli, Bongaon, North-24 Parganas,West Bengal, India.
-à For all correspondences
please use this address
[Paschinmara, Bongaon,
North 24 Parganas, West Bengal , India.{Permanent
Residence)] [FOR CORRESPONDENCE
PURPOSE TILL FURTHER NOTICE]
Kolkata address: Will
be notified as and when I am available on medical consideration.
ATTACHMENTS
1. 100+ Reminder [Copies already available
with you]
2. Compensation claim letter dated 22-12-2012 [Copies already available with you]
3. SUBJECT OF LETTERS WILL
SPEAK FOR ITSELF
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
CLAIM ON
RAILWAYS DATED 22-12-2012
Silence, Neglect, Ignorance to PWD gives a berth for
compensation claim.
Saturday,
22 December, 2012 6:24 PM
From:
"Chinmay
Kar" <chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in>
To:
"V.Mittal CRB"
Message contains attachments
 
Disabler's Desk -
I am a Retd. Sr. Citizen (68 yrs), Hemaparasis Disabled (60%), right
side of body fully paralyzed, cannot move out side with out an escort but can
only operate computer / internet with unusual left hand to communicate rest
part of world especially in connection with social welfare works for
betterment to old age disability and disabled persons Received 17 Railway
Awards during later part services at Metro Railway-Kolkata but as a Retd.
Disabled Sr.Citizen neglected / ignored by all - Chinmay Kar
************************************************************
[A CASE OF SR.CITIZEN, PARALYZED DISABLED,
CANNOT MOVE OUT SIDE W/O ESCORT & fully
dependent on e-governance system]
To
Sri. Vinay
Mittal,
Chairman,
Railway Board,
Indian
Railways, New
Delhi .
Sub:
REMINDER- 136- Dated. 18-12-2012
Since= 07-06-2009
[Silence by Railways for 2188 Days]
Ref: 136
Reminders
Priya
Mahoday,
A very simple prayer made
above on necessity & Humanity ground by a Retd. Disabled, Sr.Citizen of India, Humanitarian prayers made through 136 letters / reminders may
please be seen. Every appeal cum reminders is self explanatory. Railway
did not acknowledge receipt nor a response made so far. Railways cannot deny
receipt of136 letters / reminders mail from me
Since the undersigned, a paralyzed Disabled (entire right side of the body
paralyzed) can’t move without an escort certified by a CMS of Railway
Hospital submitted an appeal to highest authority of railways to allow his
attendant / escort to travel in the same coach with me on the pass granted to
me as per prevailing rules. Normally an attendant / escort has to travel at
general sleeper coach 5 / 6 coaches away from the coach traveled by the pass
holder and as such does not helpful to a Disabled like the undersigned.
Situation being as mentioned above do our respected Chairman Sahab can deny
that:-
1) By way of remaining silent for 2188+ days, even after issue
of 136 letters/reminders tantamount to a Neglect / Ignore / insult made to a
Senior Citizen, Paralyzed Disabled, can’t move without an escort, made by
railway authority?
2) By way of remaining silent over three years from the date
of receipt of 1st appeal made on 07-06-2009 allowed this physically disabled person (68 yrs)
deteriorating physical handicapped ness to further extent. Railways silence
caused my deterioration condition of Disability further which could have been
avoided provided Railways at the initial stage of my appeal communicated the
Disability of Railways to help / accept the simple prayer of a Senior
Citizen, Paralyzed Disabled, who can’t move without an escort. Hence Railway
is totally responsible for the damage done to a Disabled
Railways could not consider a very simple prayer of a
genuine very aged extreme Disabled Person though all papers / documents
relating to eligibility to get an escort to travel with the Disabled in
question but arranged charity distribution of very costly free pass to a
large number of different persons of the society having absolutely No
connection with Railway or Railway works at all and thus made a Differential
Treatment with a Sr.Citizen, Paralyzed Disabled Person. Please see the
provisions made for PWDs:- [Office of the United Nations High
Commissioner for Human Rights
Declaration on the
Rights of Disabled Persons
Proclaimed by General
Assembly resolution 3447 (XXX) of 9
December 1975
3) Railways silence to the appeals of an Aged, Paralyzed
Disabled debarred him in observing / availing religious as well as pilgrimage
tours to Thirupati, Kamrup, Tarapith Vaishna Devi etc. This is to be noted
that a Paralyzed disabled, can’t move outside with out an escort & if
escort cannot accompany the Disabled Person the deserved journey cannot be
made by Disabled in question. By such action Railways are responsible for
preventing me to avail the fundamental rights of performing religious
customary as provided in constitution.
4) Had Railways at the very initial stage of the appeal made
three years back expressed their DISABILITY to help an extreme Paralyzed
Disabled Person then the question of Differential Treatment, Ignore, Neglect,
Insult, Payment of compensation to a PWD would have not arisen. I would have
make some adjustment & proceeded for pilgrimage. Amount claimed towards compensation is
Rupees seven lakhs and fifty thousand only.
Hope that Mittal Sahab, well conversant with my case will
render proper justice to this Disabled at the fag end of life and oblige,
Thanking you, Yours faithfully,
Attachment: TWO
Chinmay Kar 22nd Dec’'2012
[Due to extreme disability reasons E- governance correspondence
solicited]
[Available
on Skype, gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
kyinu1955@ gmail.com
Visit
respective Web site for more details:
Human Right Activist- Yahoo Group, Active
Member Disability International Friendship Forum, Humanist Party of India , DAND, NCHRO, ADR. Member all leading
Disabled forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter,
MySpace, Linkedin, Orckut etc etc & Ex. President (for a decade up
to 21.02.03 - become hemaparasis disabled) of Siddeswari Kali Mandir &
Seva Sangha, Gandhipalli, Bongaon, North-24 Parganas,West Bengal,
India.
-à For all correspondences please use this address
A/III, Mala Apptt , 57,
B.P.Road, Paschimputiary, Kolkata-700041 [ India ] {Ty.residence on medical consideration
[Paschinmara,
Bongaon, North 24 Parganas, West Bengal, India.{Permanent Residence)] [NOT FOR
CORRESPONDENCE PURPOSE]
Copy to for
information and necessary action.:- hm@nic.in , soniagandhi@sansad.nic.in , pmosb@pmo.nic.in , Sonia_Gandhi@congress.com, , ccpd@hub.nic.in , cabinetsy@nic.in , mr@rb.railnet.gov.in , enable@un.org , crpd@ohchr.org , duangnarumol@apcdfoundation.org
, InfoDesk@ohchr.org , sgnhrc@nic.in , helpline@rb.nic.in , presidentofindia@rb.nic.in
|
