Thursday, July 8, 2010

A picture what has happened to: -->

Dear friends, Well wishers,
All of you might have seen the 'Marriage photographs of my daughter on 27-06-2010' at web site DIF, orkut, facebook etc. by this time. Kindly spare a few minutes more to know the darkenside of the episode placed below.
Thanking you all.

Chinmay Kar 8th July '2010
[Due to extreme disability reasons E- governance correspondence solicited]
[Available on Skype, gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
chinmaykar@hotmail.com
Visit Web site for more details: http://www.kodakkal.ning.com
Human Right Activist- Yahoo Group, Active Member Disability International Friendship Forum, Humanist Party of India, NCHRO, Member all leading Disabled forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, Linkedin, Orckut etc
A/III,Mala Apptt, 57, B.P.Road, Paschimputiary, Kolkata-700041 [India]

Disabler's Desk - I am a Retd. Sr. Citizen, Hemaparasis Disabled (60%), right side of body fully paralyzed, cannot move out side with out an escort but can only operate computer / internet with unusual left hand to communicate rest part of world especially in connection with social welfare works as a Humanright Activist etc for betterment to old age disability and disabled persons -Chinmay Kar
>>>>>>>>>> **** <<<<<<<<<<<

TRADITIONAL INDIAN RICH CULTURE OF RESPECT TO AN OLD AGED PERSON  NEGLECTED, IGNORED OR?


As the old aged mother of the groom is seriously ill, under compelled circumstances I had to agree and arrange marriage of my daughter with in a vary short time (27.06.2010). For arranging this marriage ceremony (without Dowry) besides my small savings I was in urgent need of funds by way of a loan of Rs.1.5lks from any other available financial sources. Government of India is very much concerned / sympatric to old aged / disabled, Sr.Citizen Government pensioners and arranged some instant help through bank loans etc. Against such a provision made through UCO bank (as available from web site) for getting mortgage loan, the UCO, Bongaon branch was contacted. Unfortunately UCO Bank / Bongaon Branch opined that they can give loans for business only and not for any marriage purpose.

My official pension a/c banker i.e. SBI / TNT Studio Branch, Tollygunje, Kolkata-700040 was contacted. As usual this bank is very much helpful to each and every customers including this extreme disabled person apprised me that they can only give me a loan for Rs.1.10lks against 'Sr.Citizen' entitlement as per prevailing rules. I had to agree and received the interest bearing loan of Rs. One lakh and ten thousand only. Since my minimum requirement was Rs.1.5lks, I had made a prayer to Chairman / SBI [India] to consider granting loan for Rs.1.5lks as a special case to "Extreme Disabled" Sr.Citizen. Prayer was made to Sri. O.P. Bhatt, Chairman / State Bank of India considering the fact that any special consideration on merits of the case, departure from prevailing rules, relaxations / exemptions / special provisions if any to "Person With Disability" (so long not considered by SBI / India) can be approved / considered only by the highest authority of the concerned organization and not others. Prayer made to Chairman / SBI [India] on 12-05-2010, & since date of marriage fixed on 27-06-2010 reminders issued on 19 & 20-05-2010, "SHIMOGA DISTRICT PHYSICALLY HANDICAPPED WELFARE SANGHA[Regd]" was also kind enough to recommend my prayer to Chairman /SBI (India) vide letter dated 14-05-2010 to Chairman / SBI [India] < chairman@sbi.co.in > for consideration, further reminders issued are:- on

26.05.2010, 30.05.2010, 03.06.2010, 07.06.2010, 14-06-2010, 17.06.2010 & 20.06.2010 and finally on 23-06-2010
As I was too worried for money and for want of a final decision from Sri.Bhatt I had requested Sri. Bhatt, Chairman / SBI [India] to be feel free and let me know that in the event he is unable to consider the request of a PWD. You all will be surprised to know that no response received from Chairman / SBI (India) even though a large number of letters and reminders issued. (Most of the letters & reminders are available on different web sites / Disabled forum). However since there was no other alternate available with me, on 25-06-2010 I had to take a private loan for the balance amount needed by paying interest @ 4% pm. I would have appreciated if a timely refusal to a PWD is received from Highest Authority (addressee) of SBI / India so that this poor disabled old man could avoid payment of high interest. Probably Sri.Bhatt, being very much cautious about his status, felt it as a below dignity to write to a Disabled Sr. Citizen and neglected, ignored the issue. I, really unable to understand why a gentleman cannot spare few seconds to write 'Yes' or "No" as a courtesy measure to an aged person of the society in pursuance with very rich Indian traditional culture.

One another interesting case to be mentioned here: -

Immediate after the scheduled marriage on 27-06-2010 I received a sue-motto letter No. Kol / RM-IV / Comp/ 204 dated 25-06-2010 (Copy at attachment) on 29-06-2010 from one Regional Manager- Kolkata. Since I have addressed letters to Sri. O.P.Bhatt, Chairman / SBI (India) and sought his decision only and as such this letter is uncalled for. I have not addressed any letter to said regional manager. However the following are observed:-
1. In subject col. of the letter it is recorded " COMPLAINT DATED 13.05.2010 PENSION LOAN FROM T.N.T.STUDIO BRANCH".
Who has made "COMPLAIN" to this regional manager? Only a prayer made to Chairman for his decision.

2. (a) Contents of the letter are a reproduction / replica of what has been explained / agreed to / undisputed. A simple prayer was made on subject loan issue to rise the ceiling for "Disabled Person" to Chairman only who can exercise his discretionary powers to consider or reject a prayer on merits. Thus this is an unnecessary correspondence.

2 (b) As regards sentences "we are guided by the directives of the Bank (A) / Govt. (B) / RBI (C) therefore..."

(A) Who has disputed this?

(B) Unless "Govt." as quoted, relevant circular restricting Chairman /SBI [India] to exercise his discretionary powers to consider / approve a case referred / represented to him is made available or reference no. & date is quoted it is useless to mention for what so ever purpose.

(C) This is most important. Deputy General Manager / Reserve Bank of India's letter in connection with Pension Loan to me is reproduced below for ready appreciation. R.M's claim is purely contradictory and misguiding.

" Sanction of loan or otherwise is a commercial decision of individual banks and RBI cannot intervene in it.

However, we have forwarded your email to SBI for necessary action as they may deem fit.

With kind regards,

B.N.Lonare, DGM
Customer Service Department,
Reserve Bank of India,"
While our respected POI, GOI acting through the PM and FM etc expressed their sympathy to all PWDs of the society and desired to help them in all respect as far as possible by all concerned, negative attitude by certain authority contrary to the sprit of GOI could not be appreciated.
However I am grateful to all my friends, well wishers round the world including Bank personnel those who expressed sympathy, concern to this poor Disabled Sr.Citizen and wanted to help. Thank you very much for sparing a few minutes with this old man.

Chinmay Kar 8th July '2010
[Due to extreme disability reasons E- governance correspondence solicited]
[Available on Skype, gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
chinmaykar@hotmail.com
Visit Web site for more details: http://www.kodakkal.ning.com
Human Right Activist- Yahoo Group, Active Member Disability International Friendship Forum, Humanist Party of India, NCHRO, Member all leading Disabled forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, Linkedin, Orckut etc
A/III,Mala Apptt, 57, B.P.Road, Paschimputiary, Kolkata-700041 [India]

Thursday, July 1, 2010

Disabled Escort issue- Pending with Railways

01-07-2010 – REMINDER (36)

Smt. Mamata Banerjee , Minister of Railways, GoI, Rail Bhaban, Rai Sinha Road , New Delhi - 110001. ,

Sri. Vivek Sahay, CRB - Railway Board, New Delhi .

Respected Madam / Sir,

Sub: Long outstanding Humanitarian consideration prayer by a Hemaparasis Disabled
(60%), Retd.Rly, Sr. Citizen -

Ref: My prayers (1) Dated. 30-06-2009 (26) Dated. 21.04.2010
(2) Dated. 10-08-2009 (27) Dated 29.04.2010
(3) Dated. 01-09-2009 (28) Dated 07.05.2010
(4) Dated. 09-10-2009 (29) Dated 13.05.2010
(5) Dated. 22-10-2009 (30) Dated 17.05.2010
(6) Dated. 03-11-2009 (31) Dated 26.05.2010
(7) Dated. 16-11-2009 (32) Dated. 02.06.2010
(8) Dated. 30-11-2009 (33) Dated 10.06.2010
(9) Dated. 10-12-2009 (34) Dated. 17.06.2010
(10) Dated. 21.12.2009 (35) Dated. 23.06.2010
(11) Dated 29.12.2009
(12) Dated 04.01.2010
(13) Dated 10.01.2010
(14) Dated 17.01.2010
(15) Dated 25.01.2010
(16) Dated 01.02.2010
(17) Dated 08.02.2010
(18) Dated 22.02.2010
(19) Dated 01-03-2010
(20) Dated 08.03.2010
(21) Dated 15.03.2010
(22) Dated 22.03.2010
(23) Dated 28.03.2010
(24) Dated 05.04.2010
(25) Dated 15.04.2010 All E-mail letters, Hard copy of Prayer
received by RB, all documents sent by mails
may kindly be connected for ready
reference]



The basic prayer is to allow his attendant / Escort free to travel in 2nd class may be allowed to travel along with his extreme disabled person who cannot move for what so ever purpose, a Comp. Rly Pass holder as detailed in his earlier prayers. The prayer made on Humanitarian Ground and as a Special case considering the difficulties explained in details vide series of letters referred to at above stands good. You are aware that pending approval this disabled had to cancel the intended south India pilgrimage tour at the fag end of his life.

Now this Retd. Disabled Sr.Citizen intends to visit pending south India pilgrimage spots along with his wife (aged 60 yrs a sickly asthmatic patient) only by this Nov'10 provided an escort is allowed to accompany me as prayed. A 60 year aged sickly lady cannot serve me as an escort which surely you will agree. [Since only daughter eligible to get pass (Sikha Kar) married on 27-06-2010 now onwards only myself and wife, both Sr.Citizen will travel with pass henceforth]**

Again a time to time reminding this case have become necessary for a Hemaparasis Disabled(60%) right side of body fully paralyzed, cannot move out side to chase a case at different office as his prayer is not receiving attention by the Railway Administration probably due to very much tight schedule now a day. Considering this reminder twice in a week will henceforth will be issued. A certificate of Government Doctor (SDMO/Bongaon, Govt. of W.B) on Rly standard format is enclosed for ready appreciation who has certified that I cannot move without an escort. As committed earlier, a further certificate issued by Chief Medical Supdt. / M.Rly. / Kolkata that I cannot move without an escort is enclosed as further documentation.

Hope this disabler’s case may get humanitarian consideration at any moment by a kind hearted human being and his prayer is approved. Thanking you all. Yours faithfully,
Attachments: Kindly see earlier mails sent to you referred at above with documents

Chinmay Kar 1st July '2010
[Due to extreme disability reasons E- governance correspondence solicited]
[Available on Skype, gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
chinmaykar@hotmail.com
Visit my Web site: http://www.chinmaykar.ning.com or http://www.kodakkal.ning.com
Human Right Activist- Yahoo Group, Active Member Disability International Friendship Forum, Humanist Party of India, NCHRO, Member all leading Disabled forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, Linkedin, Orckut etc
A/III, Mala Apptt, 57, B.P.Road, Paschimputiary, Kolkata-700041 [India]

** Only para 2 above may kindly be noted by GM / M.Rly / Kolkata's office