For attention of Sri.Bhattacherjee all well wishers and all others online….
This is a clear case of “DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT TO A POOR DISABLED PERSON”. You might have noticed that some few months back a similar question was initiated by some officials of Government of India in respect of citizenship of a famous sportsman, citizen of the country ( INDIA ) but the said motivated case initiated by a sector of officials had to be dropped at the timely intervention by the highest dignitaries of the nation. Similar thing happened to Sri. Ashim Ghosh, a poor post polio physically disabled (80%) person having all requisite certificates* to establish his eligibility to get an EPIC being denied for some reason or other, one plea to other** over a decade, but alas! since this poor man doesn’t have any VIP, Lawyers or highest dignitaries as a referee for him he has become a victim of official activeness.. Please go through the order made District Magistrate / North-24 Parganas / West Bengal / India on 04-10-2010 but intentional delay for circulation by 56 days (30-11-2010) so that entry of this victim can be deprived in any way. Incidentally the Ld. Advocate on record Sri. Anirban Chakroborty, who was to submit some essential documents could not attend on 04-10-2010 before DM due to his illness prayed extension of time received by DM on 04-10-2010 was ignored but preferred to issue a hasty order on the same day but dispatched after 56 days. A new plea included that the mother of victim is fake. Name of the person confirming fake is essentially required to be specifically indicated so that the same may be encountered with the concerned person with photography for past three decades (available with this mail) and medically etc.. The more you go through the large number of contradictory correspondences made by the department, already made available on different web sites; you will be more and surprised. The specific reasons for such a hasty action to dismiss the case and deliberate delay in communicating the order by 56 days is they are aware that reason of dismissal will be established by lawful documents and medically and will tantamount to establish that intentional harassment made to the victim over a decade.
As such you may like to get more information’s from concerned DM. ECI is already conversant with this case. There is no reason to believe that ECI of the country is a paper tiger. They have been requested to investigate from their own machinery instead of depending on routine channel eyes to find out loose threads. All documents, correspondences are attached with every reference / available on respective related web sites for ready reference. As such no need to hunt up and waste time. The more you will go through documents, official correspondences & photography’s, all attached with this mail you will be more surprised to find how a disabled (80%) harassed, neglected, insulted for disability and Differently Treated.
Chinmay Kar 159h Dec '2010 ***
[Due to extreme disability reasons E- governance correspondence solicited]
[Available on Skype, gtalk & Webcom]
chinmaykar@yahoo.co.in
chinmaykar@hotmail.com
Visit concerning Web sites for more details:
Human Right Activist- Yahoo Group, Active Member Disability International Friendship Forum, Humanist Party of India, NCHRO, Member all leading Disabled forum around the world, Member Disabled group- Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, Linkedin, Orckut etc
*** Disabler's Desk - I am a Retd. Sr. Citizen (67yrs), Hemaparasis Disabled (60%), right side of body fully paralyzed, cannot move out side with out an escort but can only operate computer / internet with unusual left hand to communicate rest part of world especially in connection with social welfare works for betterment to old age disability and disabled persons Received 17 Railway Awards during 41 year services***
A/III, Mala Apptt , 57, B.P.Road, Paschimputiary, Kolkata-700041 [ India ] {Ty.residence on medical consideration}
[ Paschinmara, Bongaon, North 24 Parganas, West Bengal , India . {Permanent Residence
Glitter Graphics
Copy to: all well wishers being sent seperately.
--- On Tue, 14/12/10, Bhabesh Bhattacherjee
From: Bhabesh Bhattacherjee
Subject: Re: Fw: [Law-Justice-HumanRights] Fw: [humanrightsactivist] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: sechome@wb.gov.in, secy-gov-wb@nic.in, "ceo-wb"
Cc: humanrightsactivist@yahoogroups.com, "Editor Telegraph"
Date: Tuesday, 14 December, 2010, 7:26 PM
Sub : Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time..[http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=12548&id=100000814118289&l=cfdaf2d096 ] – The more you go through the more you will be surprised.
Too many letters have been issued in this case by different persons from time to time but it is seen not reply received. But why is not understood. What is wrong or right is required to be brought notice of all concerned. Why a large number of contradictory letters to each other has been issue? When it has been confirmed by the victim that he do not posses Birth certificate why he is being asked to produce birth certificate some how? (all web posted letters needed be referred to). Why DM was too interested to close the hearing / case when he was aware that Ld. Advocate on record was sick and prayed an extension of time due to inability of attend hearing. DM not only closed the hearing by granting extension but dismissed the case in a hasty manner on the date of hearing i.e. 04-10-2010 but surprisingly deliberately delayed publishing of order for another 56 days i.e. on 30-11-2010. Why this is required? This action was necessary to prevent the victim to produce the required evidence. We are interested to know the factual happenings. Sri.Saha, Kar and all others may like to keep watching the case on web site.
Bhabesh Bhattacharjee 13-12-2010 C/ to - all well wishers seperately through seperate e-mails
--- On Fri, 10/12/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: Fw: [Law-Justice-HumanRights] Fw: [humanrightsactivist] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: "dm-24 pgs"
Cc: "Law Justice HRA"
Date: Friday, 10 December, 2010, 4:57 AM
Sub : Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time..[http://www.facebook.com/album.php?aid=12548&id=100000814118289&l=cfdaf2d096 ]
As the District Magistrate / N-24 Pargs, West Bengal, India personally requested not to over burden him through mails since he was busy with solving the captioned issue, we did not pursue the request made detailed below. Now that the DM has since issued orders dated 04-10-2010 but circulated due to unknown reasons on 30-11-2010. Thanks for O.O. which are / is being examined & suitable befitting words from dictionary are being searched out to greet on line for ready appreciation by all concerned.
However the concerned District Magistrate is requested to publish the detail particulars as requested vide mail dated 10-07-2010, copy placed below duly yellow hatched color. There may be no objection to furnish details as requested for public information since the same are neither secret nor endanger safety & security of public life. Incidentally no comments received on e-mail dated 28-07-2010 to DM with copy to all others for information. Keeping in view that this issue is likely going to be most important event it can be expected that Election Commission of the country might be watching through its own machinery (with out depending on administrative eyes) to find out loose threads. All documents made available to you all with relevant documentation / web sites.
Sougat Saha
Howrah, India. 09.12.2010
--- On Thu, 15/7/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: Fw: [Law-Justice-HumanRights] Fw: [humanrightsactivist] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: humanrightsactivist@yahoogroups.com
Date: Thursday, 15 July, 2010, 4:45 AM
--- On Thu, 15/7/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: Fw: [Law-Justice- HumanRights] Fw: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To:
Cc: "subham sen"
Date: Thursday, 15 July, 2010, 4:36 AM
Please see the demand / request made to provide some information’s by DM / DEO- 24 Parganas, District, West Bengal, India together with too many contradictory letters issued by different offices connected with issue of an EPIC to a 80% Disabled person, having lot of documents/certifica tes but ignored year after years due to unknown reasons by the same authority. Now it appears that the victim has furnished form 001C duly filled in together with entire certificates duly attested to DM/DEO on 05-01-2010 as directed by him on 22-12-2010. DEO by special arrangement got the documents verified on 07-01-010.
This is an appeal case and the case is presently lying with Mr.Binood Kumar, DM/DEO (Appellate Authority) i.e same authority who asked for papers vide letter dated 22-12-2010 and again in June'2010, but now under compelled circumstance wants to de shoulder his responsibility to lower authority for decision which is extremely unfortunate.
Sougat Saha 15/07/2010
--- On Sun, 11/7/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: [Law-Justice- HumanRights] Fw: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: Law-Justice- HumanRights@ yahoogroups. com
Date: Sunday, 11 July, 2010, 4:10 AM
Keeping in view that large number of identical nature of complains being reported through different news media and ECI's dissatisfaction over the issue, remedial directives in this regard, we would like to know the following for better appreciation: -
1. Number of staff and officials connected with sensitive work of electoral enrollment meant for different constituencies under DM - North 24 Parganas for more than 3 years and those working beyond 5 years in contrary to the prevailing service rules.
2. How many transfer orders made for those working in very sensitive posts beyond 3 years and cases of refusal if any?
In all fairness, concerned DM cum DEO may like to furnish above details at the earliest in the interest of administrative total fairness, discipline for appreciation by general public. A sample case is placed below for perusal. - Sougat Saha. 11-07-2010
--- On Sat, 10/7/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: Fw: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: ghoshashim88@ yahoo.in
Date: Saturday, 10 July, 2010, 2:26 PM
--- On Sat, 10/7/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: Fw: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: manjul_haldar@ yahoo.com, "chinmay kar"
Cc: bhabesh1964@ gmail.com, kamaladhikari59@ yahoo.com
Date: Saturday, 10 July, 2010, 2:22 PM
Copy for information - sougat saha
--- On Sat, 10/7/10, Sougat Saha
From: Sougat Saha
Subject: Fw: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: "dm-24 pgs"
Cc: ceo_westbengal@ eci.gov.in, humanrightsactivist @yahoogroups. com, feedback@eci. gov.in
Date: Saturday, 10 July, 2010, 2:14 PM
Keeping in view that large number of identical nature of complains being reported through different news media and ECI's dissatisfaction over the issue, remedial directives in this regard, we would like to know the following for better appreciation: -
1. Number of staff and officials connected with sensitive work of electoral enrollment meant for different constituencies under DM - North 24 Parganas for more than 3 years and those working beyond 5 years in contrary to the prevailing service rules.
2. How many transfer orders made for those working in very sensitive posts beyond 3 years and cases of refusal if any?
In all fairness, concerned DM cum DEO may like to furnish above details at the earliest in the interest of administrative total fairness and discipline - Sougat Saha .
--- On Sat, 10/7/10, Ashim Ghosh
From: Ashim Ghosh
Subject: Fw: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: sougatsaha44@ yahoo.com
Date: Saturday, 10 July, 2010, 3:21 AM
Please have a look. This has been disscussed by old aged meeting on different issues
Ashim Ghose 10.07.2010
--- On Sat, 26/6/10, Ashim Ghosh
From: Ashim Ghosh
Subject: [humanrightsactivis t] Fw: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: deonprg@gmail. com
Cc: "dm-24 pgs"
Date: Saturday, 26 June, 2010, 5:25 AM
To: DEO N24 < deonprg@gmail. com
Dear Sir,
Sub: Your letter ? No. No. 72 / Elec (D) / XII /92 / 09-10 Dated 22-02-2010
Ref: My E-mail dated.02-03- 2010, 10-04-2010 and 24-06-2010.
Your kind attention is invited to my e-mails quoted above and your e-mail dated 23.06.2010. Confirmation is yet to be received from your office.
1) Since official impropriety, deviations observed while receiving your letter? quoted above, it was considered necessary to have an official confirmation from your end so that sentence wise comments can be initiated and moved on. Confirmation still waited.
2) It further appears that my letter dated 05-01-2010 containing duly executed form 001C along with all relevant documents duly attested by gazette officer sent to you on 05-01-2010 received by your office under clear signature has not been brought to the personal knowledge of the District Magistrate / DEO, Mr. Vinood Kumar who is the Administrative Appellant Authority of the instant case. Urgent action is requested to apprise DM.
Hope you will be kind enough to initiate suitable action accordingly to dispose the long outstanding case on the basis of appeal and appeals made, by complying the requirements and strictly in pursuance with instructions and guide lines issued recently by Chief Election Commissioner of India . An early reply by Regd. Post to my residential address* and e-mail is requested. With regards. Yours faithfully,
Ashim Ghosh 26th June '2010
[Due to extreme physical disability E-governance correspondence is solicited].
ashimghosh178@ gmail.com
ghoshashim88@ yahoo.in
** From 10AM to 9.30PM on all working days I am available at my working place -" Star Electronics" , Court Road, Bongaon may kindly be noted. Permanent residential address: 533 Paschimpara, Bongaon, North 24-Parganas, West Bengal .
Copy for kind information to: -
1. dmn24p@gmail. com
2. kodakkalshivaprasad @gmail.com
3. "'LEGAL AID CELL FOR PHYSICALLY CHALLENGED'"
4. humanrightsactivist @yahoogroups. com
5. ceo_westbengal@ eci.gov.in
6. chinmaykar@yahoo. co.in
7. manjul_haldar@ yahoo.com
8. ccpd@nic.in
9. legallyspeaking. jalan@gmail. com, sundeep_jalan@ yahoo.co. in,
10. All Disability forum round the world as a member
--- On Thu, 24/6/10, Ashim Ghosh
From: Ashim Ghosh
Subject: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: "'DEO N24'"
Cc: "'dm/bst'"
Date: Thursday, 24 June, 2010, 4:25 AM
2nd occasion such case taken place. However you are requested to kindly send a hard copy of this particular e-mail duly signed by Mr. V.Kumar , District Magistrate by Registered Post to my residential address at the earliest possible for further action. My address is available at your office vide official document & documents duly attested by Govt.Gazetted officers sent to you through courier service on 05.01.2010 duly received and acknowledged by your office in response to your e-mail dated 22-12-2009. Thanking you.
Ashim Ghosh 24th June '2010
[Due to extreme physical disability E-governance correspondence is solicited].
ashimghosh178@ gmail.com
ghoshashim88@ yahoo.in
--- On Wed, 23/6/10, D M N 24 PARGANAS
From: D M N 24 PARGANAS
Subject: RE: Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
To: "'Ashim Ghosh'"
Cc: "'dm/bst'"
Date: Wednesday, 23 June, 2010, 7:52 AM
REPRODUCING THE REPLY SENT EARLIER:
Sir,
Appeal is to be filed within 15 days of the order of the ERO. Since the period of appeal is long over, you may like to file a fresh petition in form 6 for enrolment. To be registered as elector, you would be required to submit the following documents:
1. Proof of Indian Citizenship
2. Age proof
3. Proof of ordinary residence
ERO is being advised to entertain your request even if sent by email along with the enclosures. As a special case, ERO may pl send a person with the print of your email (if all documents found in order) to your address to obtain your signature and verify original so that you do not have to travel to the office.
Hope this should take care of your concern.
With best wishes.
DEO
From: Ashim Ghosh [mailto:ghoshashim8 8@yahoo.in]
Sent: 22 June 2010 11:45
To: DEO N24; dm-bar-wb@nic. in; dmn24p@gmail. com
Cc: dm/bst; LEGAL AID CELL FOR PHYSICALLY CHALLENGED; dm/bst; humanrightsactivist @yahoogroups. com; Chinmay Kar
Subject: Re:Issue of EPIC to Disabled differed on different pleas time to time....
MAIL dm-bar@wb.nic. in ALWAYS BOUNCING BACK AND AS SUCH DIO -NIC was REQUESTED TO ENSURE DELIVERY TO DM cum DEO and oblige
************ ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* ********* **
23-12-2009
On Wed, Dec 23, 2009 at 5:31 PM, DEO N24
Junk Score: 2 out of 10 (below your Auto Allow threshold) | Approve sender | Block sender | Block domain
Sir,
As directed by DEO & DM I would like to apprise you the following points :
We have received your mail and gone through pedantically. If you kindly place the counter part of 001C form to this end it wouyld be helpful for us to trace the case.Moreover, from your detailed representation your status as voter [i.e. AC No. / Part No. / Sl No. ] is not clear on account of which we are not ascertained whether you have enrolled as voter or not.If you kindly specify your details in this manner it would be quite helpful for us.For EPIC, you don't have to come to District HQ or SDO Office, Just fill up the 001C form duly signed (It is available in website- ceowestbengal. nic.in) along with 2 copies of photos and send it to this end. We are assuring that necessary course of action will be taken from this end.We are also forwarding the copy of your letter to Sub Divisional Officer, Bongaon for enquiry and reporting.However, we are extremely sorry for any inconvenience in this matter.
Your cooperation in this regard is highly solicited.
Thanking you ,
Officer In Charge
District Election Cell
North 24 Parganas
On Tue, Dec 22, 2009 at 11:18 AM, DIO Barasat
Kindly see DM / DEO's communication letter datd 22.12.2009 at above.
Probably DM /DEO is not briefed properly. It appears that above letter was issued as per the orders of DM / DEO. and as such as ordered / instructed by DM /DEO,form 001C along other documents submitted to DEO's office on 05-01-2010. It is further noted that the case of issue of an EPIC to a Disabled is being dragged on for years after years for some reason / plea or the other resulting extreme harassment to Disabled Persons of the Human Society. However my submission to DM cum DEO is as follows:
To
Sri. Binod Kumar, IAS
District Magistrate / DEO
Barasat, North 24-Parganas, W.B &
All officers mentioned in earlier mail dated 26-04-2010 , 05-05-2010 , 09-05-2010 & 07-06-2010
(dm-bar@wb.nic. in, wbbrs@nic.in, deonprg@gmail. com, wbbrs@hub2.nic. in,)
Your kind personal attention is once again invited to my earlier letters mentioned at above. As desired by you Form 001C duly executed/filled in along with all official documents, certificates issued by competent authority of the Govt. [ Documents "A" to "E" detailed at Attachment] duly attested by gazetted officer have been submitted to your office on 05-01-2010.
You are requested to kindly arrange issue of EPIC in favor of this extreme disabled (80%) at the earliest or convey the Administrative orders of DM / DEO [i.e. Appellate Authority] as requested vide letters mentioned at above keeping in view the latest directive and guidelines issued by the Chief Election Commissioner of India. to all concerned
As the undersigned is a Disabled (80%) cannot move freely kindly feel free to communicate through e-governance though I am residing at my official address rcorded since 1982 (age of 4 yrs) to till date i.e. over 28 yrs as per various records / documents / certificates produced before you.
With deep regards. Thanking you,
Kindly see Attachment for ready appreciation.
Ashim Ghosh 22nd June '2010
[Due to extreme physical disability E-governance correspondence is solicited].
ashimghosh178@ gmail.com
ghoshashim88@ yahoo.in
--- On Fri, 18/6/10, DEO N24
From: DEO N24
Subject: Your petition for EPIC regarding.
To: ghoshashim88@ yahoo.in
Cc: "D M N 24 PARGANAS"
Date: Friday, 18 June, 2010, 2:35 PM
Sir,
We have received your e-mails. As directed by the District Magistrate, I am to inform you that You have submitted Form 6 previously and you have not submitted appeal petition before the District Magistrate, North 24 Parganas.
You are requested to submit Form 6 with all documents afresh during the forthcoming SRER-2010 period from 9th July,2010 to 23rd July,2010 at the polling station where you are living.They will receive your petition and willl give a notice to appaer in hearing. The final Roll will be published on 7th day of September,2010. If your name do not appear in the final roll you may file appeal petition along with the receipt of your petiton before the DEO and DM, North 24 Paraganas within 15 days.
Form 6 also available at the CEO, WB website: www.ceowestbengal. nic.in
Yoursfaithfully,
Officer in Charge,
District Election Section
North 24-Parganas
****************************************************
To
Sri. Binod Kumar
DM / DEO
Barasat, 24-Parganas, W.B.
Respected Sir,
Sub: Issue of EPIC Card - An 80% Disabled unable to avail facilities offered by
Govt. for years together.
I, Sri. ASHIM GHOSH, aged 31 yrs, a post polio paralysis of both lower limbs 80% disabled person, a resident of Paschimpara, Bongaon, North 24-Parganas, West Bengal applied for issue of a Voter Identity Card to the appropriate Election Commission office at Bongaon each and every opportunity offered by Election Commission of India. Unfortunately it is found that neither EPIC has been issued nor any reasons for non acceptance of request have been intimated. In this connection all detail particulars are furnished below for appraisal of every sympatric persons of India.
[A] Applications made for enrolment as voter on standard format submitted by me and Electoral officers notice thereon for appearing for hearing are as follows.
1) Application receipt dated. 14.10.04 and hearing fixed on 12.11.04 - Attended.
2) Application receipt dated. 07.11.05 and hearing fixed on 25.11.05 - Attended
3) Application receipt No. WB-TTT-0554296 dt. Nil and hearing fixed on 09.12.00 - Attended.
4) Application receipt dated. 22.01.07 and hearing fixed on 10.02.07. - Attended.
5) Application receipt dated. 24.11.08 and hearing fixed on 15.12.08. - Attended
Result is NIL in each occasion i.e. EPIC not issued and reasons not made known. I had, though being a disabled poor person unable to move without 2 escorts had attended all hearings and chased with concerned offices but failed to get any sympathy from Election commission office. Probably Disable persons are not liked by Election Commission office to allow being a Voter of country.
[B] 1) According to North 24 Parganas District Primary School Council., School leaving certificate issued on 07.02.2007 for academic 1986-1989 my date of berth is 14.01.1978.
2) According to Bongaon High School (Estb-1886), Board Index No.: 149-125, Council Recogn. No.: F 369 / BS / (A) / 83, Certificate for session 1993-94 my date of berth is 14.01.1978.
Both the certificates have been produced ECO as an authentic documents of my residence as well as date of berth.
[C] Handicapped Certificate baering No. 2437 Dated.11.11.2003 [Code- OPH] issued in my favor by CDPO/ICDSP. Bongaon-Govt. of West Bengal is a government record showing my age, address, and disability for 80% assessed by Medical Board of the Govt.Hospital. Etc.
[D] I am a Ration Card holder bearing No. 856413 dated 13.12.1996 issued by competent authority of Govt. of West Bengal, of my residence area of the locality.
[E] I am having PAN Card bearing No. ASJPG1689E issued by Income Tax Department, Government of India.
It may kindly be seen from what has been brought out at above that although all the above said documents mentioned at above were issued by Government authority over the years and brought to the knowledge of Election Commission Officers for enrolment as a Voter by issuing an EPIC card, which they ignored for 5 occasions during the years 2004 to 2008 as detailed at above.
As I am an 80% OPD Disabled person, cannot move freely to meet and chase different officers / offices to get EPIC card, I have been NEGLECTED, IGNORED AND OTHERWISE treated, debarred to get an EPIC card. I am a very poor disabled person and in the event EPIC card is issued to me, I would have get a loan made available to Person With Disabilities under various scheme of Government of India which I am debarred due to extreme negligence / ignorance to a Disabled Person
But for my acute disability, inability to speak & to move freely to meet DM & DEO at Barasat, I would have explained in detail the case in person for better appreciation and suitable remedial actions.
In the light of matters / constraints brought out at above, I would like to request your good self to kindly pass suitable orders so that an EPIC card is issued to me at the earliest possible. All the original Documents referred to at above will be made available to requisitioned officials as and when called for. Yours faithfully,
Ashim Ghosh 17-11-2009
No comments:
Post a Comment